The Recession, Explained

October 23, 2010 by  
Filed under The Lileks Zone

Anyone who’s been awake in the last two years knows there’s contentious debate about the causes of the Great Recession. A natural contraction, exacerbated by hamfisted policies executed by people whose business experience consists of playing “Monopoly” when they were twelve? Too many bad loans given to people who showed up for closing wearing cardboard shoes and pants held up with a rope? The inevitable comeuppance you get when reality crashes into arcane financial theories? Pelosi & Co. showing up in 2006 to drape lead weights around the economy’s neck? George Soros, sitting in his underwater lair, stroking a white fluffy cat, commanding his minions to cry havoc and let loose the dogs of war?

We have an answer now. Up here in Minnesnowcold, as Hugh likes to call it, long-time Congressperson Jim Oberstar is having a hard fight against Chip Cravaack. The debates have been testy, and the audience occasionally has declined to extend the awed silence naturally owed a figure of Oberstar’s stature. From the StarTribune account of the most recent debate:

On whether Congress should extend President George W. Bush’s tax cuts,
Cravaack said they should be extended to rejuvenate business growth.

Oberstar said he would eliminate the tax break for the top 2 percent of the income bracket, claiming that the Bush tax cuts “put us into this recession that we’re in today.”

Well. There you have it. Recessions are caused by insufficient taxation. This is a novel theory to most of us, but no doubt an item of faith in Oberstar’s world. You don’t just get out of recessions by taxing more, you avoid recessions by taxing more. The fact that the economy took off after the tax cuts is irrelevant; any subsequent contraction can be laid directly at the well-shod feet of the people whose property was not subjected to the exquisitely calculated confiscation policies of the state. Brilliant.


2 Responses to “The Recession, Explained”
  1. Chris Bogdan says:

    People like Oberstar love to let you think that “the rich” [cue thunderclap] are Scrooge McDuck type characters who frolick in ginormous vaults full of cash. And, if they’re taxed an extra two per cent, it just they’re buying one less diamond encrusted Bentley this year.

    Sure, there are quite a few “old money” rich guys around who could almost fill that bill but those folks have structured incomes that allow them to get away with paying the smallest possible tax bill. Because, you know, it’s an INCOME tax and not an accumulated wealth tax. Does anyone think that Ted Turner pays the maximum rate? I’d be surprised.

  2. John Davey says:

    Are Minnesota and California the only states that are going to be immune to the 2010 Wave? I guess we have a new super power: Tsunami proof!

    If so, as a Californian, I apologize to the other states.

    Oberstar can be described thusly:

    Believes that what he thinks is morally superior to what you do.
    Believes that the ills of society can be resolved by taking something away from somebody else.
    Believes that you aren’t paying enough.
    Believes that more people are trying to cheat, than are trying to play by the rules.
    Believes that Socialism will work, we just haven’t tried hard enough yet.

    Here’s to hoping that the 2010 Wave can crest a few spots in Minnesota and California.

Important Links
Lileks Private reserve
Duanes World
Hugh Hewitt Store
  • RSS Hugh Hewitt Blog

    • “SOTU Address: No Middle Class Economics but Lots of Spin” by Clark Judge January 28, 2015
      The weekly column from Clark Judge: SOTU Address: No Middle Class Economics but Lots of Spin By Clark S. Judge: managing director, White House Writers Group, Inc.; Chairman, Pacific Research Institute Last week President Obama delivered his next to final State of the Union address. In it, he extolled “middle class economics”, which was the name he attached t […]
    • Rorke Denver on “American Sniper” January 27, 2015
      Rorke Denver, a SEAL commander whose role in the film Act of Valor and his book Damn Few have made him one of the most in-demand speakers in America, was a SEAL Team Three colleague of Chris Kyle, and Denver writes about the movie, the controversy and his brother-in arms in today’s Wall Street Journal.  Don’t miss it.